|
Private Dancer 6:27 Sun Jan 21
Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
|
Spain - Iniesta
Italy - Baggio
Germany - Beckenbauer
|
|
|
Replies - Newest Posts First ( Show In Chronological Order)
Takashi Miike
11:18 Thu Jan 25
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
after the 'debate' programme on sky last night they had a la liga icons thing featuring beckham. it showed all his goals and many of his assists and it highlighted what a great player he was to shine in a team filled with stars like figo, roberto carlos, fat ronaldo, raul & zidane
|
goose
11:44 Wed Jan 24
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Russ - Gazza, Des Walker, Paul Scholes & Chris Waddle.
|
Westham67
11:31 Wed Jan 24
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Xavi Hernandez
Pirlo
Beckenbauer
|
Russ of the BML
11:05 Wed Jan 24
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Private Dancer 3:12 Wed Jan 24
Agreed. I was referring to the 'in my lifetime' bit.
Moore, Charlton and I would also suggest Billy Wright who were all world class in their day.
|
Son of Sam
11:03 Wed Jan 24
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Its got to be one of Gunther Sachs, Gianni Agnelli or Rudolph Valentino
|
Private Dancer
3:12 Wed Jan 24
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
In my humble I'd suggest Moore, Charlton and Gascoigne are the 3 best English players.
|
Russ of the BML
6:40 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Goose:
Maybe Gazza?
|
goose
11:30 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
its very telling that you can list many names from those countries to fill a team of world class players. if you added england to the list who do you have?
very few in my lifetime.
|
Russ of the BML
11:22 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Mart O 4:19 Tue Jan 23
Loads with a shout. Best LB I ever see was Andreas Brehme. What a player.
|
Russ of the BML
11:21 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Nice TM. That is some team!
|
tanman
10:33 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Good work TM - that team would take some beating!
|
Mart O
4:19 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
I have to say, that is good work TM. Hard to say much better than that.
Breitner's the only one I would have an issue with, funnily enough, as it seems a bit harsh on Berti Vogts who actually played RB alongside him. Philip Lahm's another one worth a shout.
|
Takashi Miike
3:55 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
I had to do that for Breitner who was a left back but so good he could have played anywhere
|
Private Dancer
3:50 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
TM - Good work that.
I was a big fan of Ballack so would like to find room for him.
|
Takashi Miike
3:40 Tue Jan 23
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
a greatest combined team of the three nations?
Buffon
Breitner - Baresi - Beckenbauer - Maldini
Xavi - Matthaus - Pirlo
Baggio - G.Muller - Iniesta
|
mallard
7:00 Mon Jan 22
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Butragueno
Pirlo
Voller
|
Swiss.
6:41 Mon Jan 22
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Iniesta
Maldini
Matthaus
|
Russ of the BML
6:28 Mon Jan 22
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Hani 5:41 Mon Jan 22
It's not as cut and dry. Very similar players. Baggio more tricky. Both amazing.
Del Piero much more decorated with a world cup, Champions League, UEFA cup and 5 Serie A titles.
Baggio only 2 Serie A titles and UEFA cup. It's not particularly as well decorated as you'd think someone of Baggio's class would be.
Both scored similar amounts of goals but again Del Piero pips it for amount although Baggio has better goals per game ratio.
I love them both. They are both footballing gods in my eyes.
|
Lily Hammer
6:24 Mon Jan 22
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Spain - Pablo Picasso
Italy - Giacomo Casanova
Germany - Joseph Goebbels
Always on the pull, this mob. Jack rabbits.
|
Hani
5:41 Mon Jan 22
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Anyone that picks Del Piero over Baggio needs shooting.
|
Eggbert Nobacon
2:33 Mon Jan 22
Re: Who is the greatest player to come out of Spain, Italy and Germany?
|
Kepa Blanco
Antonio Nocerino
Savio
|
|
|
|
